The one per row rule is the engine of every murder sudoku. Each row and each column holds exactly one person. So every time you place someone, you also remove a whole row and a whole column from everyone else. Use that well, and the grid collapses fast.
This is the third of our ten murder sudoku tips. It builds on where to start a logic puzzle, so read that first if you have not yet.
What the one per row rule really means
On a 5×5 map, there are five people and five rows. Therefore, each row holds exactly one of them. The same goes for columns. In fact, this is the oldest rule in grid puzzles. It comes straight from the Latin square.
As a result, placing one person always shuts eight other squares on a 5×5 map: four in the row and four in the column. That is a third of the board, gone in one move.
How to close rows and columns quickly
After each placement, draw a light line through the rest of that row and column. Alternatively, put a small dot in each closed square. The method matters less than the habit. What matters is that you never forget a closed line.
Then, look again at the clues you could not use before. Very often, a clue that seemed vague now points at one square.
The snowball effect
Here is why the one per row rule feels so powerful. Imagine a 4×4 map. You place the major in B3. Now row 3 and column B are closed. Suppose the butler must be in column D, and two of his squares were in row 3. Suddenly, he has only one option left.
Next, you place the butler. That closes another row and column. Consequently, the last two people often have only one square each. Four placements, two of them forced by the rule alone.
Common mistakes
First, solvers forget the victim. The victim also takes one row and one column, so place them like everyone else. Second, people close a row but forget the column. Third, some solvers mark lines too heavily, which hides room labels. Use a light pencil instead.
Practise on gentle maps
The Rookie cases in Sleuthdoku Volume 1 show this effect clearly, because the maps are small. On the 7×7 boards of Sleuthdoku Mastermind, however, the same habit saves you from long dead ends. Travellers can test it on the move with the World Tour, where every map is a famous place.
Keep the one per row rule in mind on every case. It is simple, it is reliable, and it is always working for you.



